3 Rules for Academic Writing with AI

Concerns about “AI Plagiarism” are overblown and come from a place of arrogance and fear.

Ironically, schools and universities, which should be about learning, have instead become all about task completion.

Plagiarism, cheating, and shortcuts will always be a concern where that is the focus.

If the goal is task completion, constant vigilance is required, because everyone will want to complete that as soon and as quickly as possible.

If, however, the goal is to actually learn something, our assignments must spark curiosity1 rather than a task list.

Everyone knows that learning can be hard and requires thinking and processing.

This will focus solely on the writing aspect from a student perspective. I’ll include something else later about teaching in an age of AI.

Have Integrity

Writing can take as much time as you will give it. Mark Twain John Locke Blaise Pascal is alleged to have concluded a long letter with this phrase:

I would have written a shorter letter, but I didn’t have time. 2

The writing process is deep and unique for each person, and it takes time. When you need to write something, on deadline especially, it just takes time to write well.

AI can speed that process up, but there are many other things that speed that process up as well.

Nobody wants another 500 words on how you wrote what you wrote. And you don’t need to cite the many different graphic organizers you may use to organize your thoughts beforehand.

But, if you’re using ideas and thoughts that are not your own, it is an act of integrity to cite your sources and share what came from whom in your writing.

My philosophy on students writing with AI: If you’re going to use AI to write the whole thing, please let me know, and I’ll use AI to grade it all. That way, nether of us waste time on it.

I’ve also said that if you’re using AI to just get it done and check a box, please let me know so I don’t waste any time reading and giving feedback. And you can have the A grade (since grades are made up anyway).

If you only take this step, you needn’t worry about anything going forward.

Use AI To Improve Your Thoughts, Not Create Them

In my first year of college, I did especially poorly on a writing assignment in one of my classes. My professor suggested I go to the writing lab.

So I did.

The writing tutor, a junior English major, gave me plenty of feedback and essentially rewrote my paper in an academic tone, but didn’t change any of my ideas.

It was in the era of track changes on Microsoft Word, and I clicked, “accept change” about 200 times and then turned it in.

I didn’t do any other work. My grade was substantially better.

My professor appeared pleased, and I decided that was good enough.

Here’s the thing, the tutor improved what I had already written. He didn’t make new arguments for me, nor did he make other major changes. But it showed me something that I didn’t understand: how to write for that particular professor3

When it comes to using AI in learning environments, don’t use the AI to do your work for you.

Let me share a brief story here.

My oldest daughter is 18 and is going to start sending out Christmas cards. Well, she also has Down syndrome, which limits her ability to communicate.

But anyone who knows her and would want a Christmas card, knows that she has a big personality and deep beliefs and dreams.

So, she typed up a Christmas card. And this is what she wrote:

May 1 I turn 18  Fun run my family and friends they go to my fun run they love me - donate a money for the Shiners hospital    $3000 dollars  Gradation   I am really Gradation at  Ferris high school    Singles ward  - my calling greeter,  go go to family home evening to institute  Speaking at Gonzaga - I was a guest speaker at Gonzaga University talking about my experience in school. Thanks Mrs Jacobson for inviting me. It was so fun. Next time I want a limo!  I want to go there everyone cheer my name Katya Katya then tee my fans they love me so much

Getting that, you’d be hard pressed to really understand, but that’s how she talks and that’s what you get.

So I sat down with her and ChatGPT and worked through what she really wanted to say. And this is the result:

Dear Family and Friends, I graduated from Ferris High School this year! I am so proud I turned 18 this May! I am so happy. My friends and family came to my fun run. We raised $3,000 for Shriners Hospital! That makes me proud This year, I want to raise $5,000 for Shriners Hospital. I’m asking all of you to help me reach my goal! At church, I have my calling as a greeter. I love saying hello to everyone. I also go to family home evening and institute classes I have an awesome job! I work at Ace Hardware for three days every week. I love my internship. I got to speak at Gonzaga University! My teacher, Mrs. Jacobson, invited me to talk about my school experiences. Everyone cheered my name - “Katya! Katya!” It was amazing. Next time, I want to ride in a limo! Love, Katya

You’ll notice, no doubt that a couple things were added to what she originally wrote. Through the process of chatting with ChatGPT, we realized she missed a couple things that were important to the letter, so we prompted ChatGPT to add those things.

My friend and history teacher Aaron Makelky says, “What is amazing about ChatGPT and tools like it is that a teacher or professor should never have to read poor writing again.”4

Remember, You Are the Author

I got some great advice many years ago, from my college English professor Debbie Bright.

She said, “Don’t forget Jethro, you are the author, and all the editors in the world (or AI tools that may exist) can’t know what your real intent is in writing something, so you need to be OK with rejecting their suggestions if they are wrong.”

I remember this advice because previous to this, all my interactions in writing were with the teachers and professors who were smarter than me and always telling me what I was doing wrong.

She taught me that my ideas mattered—and that editors, even the best, don’t get the final say.5

I’ve still had plenty of bad ideas since then, but I’ve always remembered that I am the ultimate decider of what has meaning and what I want to say.

The AI can’t be me. It can’t be you.

Only you can be you.

So, sure, use what ever tools you can to make you the best version of yourself, but don’t try to let someone or something else be you, because it can’t.

  1. I did ask AI for feedback on this writing, and this “spark curiosity phrase is the first one suggesting I agreed with. You can see the whole chat thread here. Perhaps my favorite piece of feedback was that I should have more empathy towards AI skeptics, but I don’t agree with that. I am intentionally harsh toward skeptics because I believe the skeptics are skeptical for the wrong reasons—nuance that AI probably can’t pick up on. 

  2. AI seems to suffer the same malady. It cannot be succinct ever, it seems. 

  3. This is another problem that warrants more focus than we have time for here, but when the audience is solely the professor, there’s little value in creating anything. It’s partly why I’m publishing everything (including my notes) for my doctoral program 

  4. I’m pretty sure he said that on this OSPI Graduation Equity Webinar, but it may have been in the presenter debrief afterward. 

  5. This advice from the AI better aligns with what I wanted to say, but didn’t quite have the words for. Honestly, I wouldn’t have used an em dash there, but I’m leaving it to see how it feels. Look at the transcript of the interaction to see what the original line was. 

Notes mentioning this note

There are no notes linking to this note.


Here are all the notes in this site, along with their links, conveniently visualized as a graph.

1 tip i would give an educator to start using ai...Communication CardsHome VisitsSchoolx is here. get your copy todayAPWorkshopPresentations and SpeakingAdlerian psychology in schoolsAI Easy and HardToolsOrganic Skills are the New Soft SkillsOn Lasting ForeverSites I want to model this site afterBest Year EverInstructional Coaches MastermindCUES 2014District MastermindsFamily GoalsFETC22FOCUSIdeal WeekImpactMastermindNational Principal's ConferenceObserveOnline Observation FormPhotographersPlanning PeriodASCD PlayRewire19Scales and Goals 2014SchoolXSeminarSponsorshipsSurveyTraumaUCET 2014How We Use AI In SchoolsSchoolX Book Study - Transform your School with...SchoolX Book Study - Transform your School with...SonderSchedules are a big puzzle, and I like puzzlesNot all screen time is created equal2 Keys to Building CommunityA decade never to be forgotten3 Rules for Academic Writing with AI3 things i'm interested in right now5 best rti episodes on transformative principal5 ways our edu system would be different if...50 Questions to Ask to Solve Problems5rs5sigma20Nobody cares about our life as much as we doNew Disease: NovolibrochitatWhat I've learned from doing 6000 burpees in 40...A summary of my ship30 writingsAccelerated learningA less annoying cookie bannerAdd Fathom Analytics to your Obsidian Publish siteA Live Demo Site for a SaaS productAdntbf roadmapAdding a Little Complexity to Make Things More...AI As a Fundamental ExpectationAI Can do Anything, But Not Something SpecificAI Produces and Your Brain DevelopsAi leader office hours june 2025Advanced teacher's prompts (54)All parents want their kids to be successfulExploring Descript's Agentic EditingAn overview of prompt engineering for educatorsAnyone interested in fundraising should listen to...Argentinian Food - Fast Sunday Family Feast for...Big impact mixerBook fair controversy at Prairie Hill sparks...Three reasons you should have a podcast to go with...Based on what you know about meBIM January 25 - Breakout Problem SolvingBe a creator, not a consumerBIM February 2025 - Experiments[Big Impact Mixer] - Are My Social Posts Any Good?BIM May - What are your Gifts?Apprenticeships for the 21st CenturyAssessment (58)Assessment and evaluation (50)[Big Impact Mixer] - Vision, Category Design, 10...[Big Impact Mixer] - MiraclesAssumptionsBim april creating a personalized newsletterBrooks duncan on handwritten notesBuilding classroom community (50)Building parent and community partnerships (50)Compass Among usJanuary - MolcajeteFast Sunday Family Feast - A Jones Family...February - Borscht and PelmeniHow I lost 70 Pounds in a Sustainable WayHow i got my wife to stop nagging me[Big Impact Mixer] - Experiments FollowupFrameworksI was quoted in a story from Parents MagazineEdit an episode with me (full podcast production...Don't call it a Substack. - Anil DashHoliness to the Lord in Everyday LifeFit looks like gritLearning is like a springFollowing up on my post ai counselor botsDelusional dreams of excess freedomJethro's Appearances and Media ElsewhereIrish Food - March 2025Why the Ebenezer is so Important in Come Thou...Guatemalan Food for April 2025Building an App I will use DailyEducatorsCan we trust the ai?Candy teacher referralCaroline classroom observationTransforming Old Content into Engaging Case Study...Chatgpt prompts for educatorsClassroom creativity(55)Classroom differentiation (50)Classroom discipline (50)Classroom environment (50)Classroom gamification (50)Classroom management (52)Classroom technology integration (50)ClippingsThere’s no such thing as learning loss or learning...Collaboration (54)Convertkit essential workflowsCulturally responsive teaching (50)Dan koe's writer's bootcampData dashboardDay 1 ship30Day 17 the 1 app i can’t live without for podcast...December - Brazilian Feijoada“Your Decision, My Decision, Our Decision”: A...Differentiated instruction (100)FSFF May 2025 - Korean FoodFSFF June 2025 - Good Ol' American FoodDo People Call You for Advice?Effective feedback (54)Election Day, but no TrustEthan Mollick on Knowing When to Use AIEverything AIExplicit teaching (54)How i got started in leadershipHow i would start my online presence todayHow I write a dissertation extremely fastHow writing helped me present betterHow to Be a Transformative Principal By Jethro...How This Site is BuiltHow to use mint mobile's minternational passIf I were a ProfessorShould I use AI for to Install Omarchy on a...Join the Compassionate Classroom Global Card...Just subscribe to these youtube channelsLeadership vs managementLearning is a lifelong processLesson planning (50)NewslettersLong sentencesListen LaterLucky MeatMiraclesMove from blogtalkradio to transistorMaking “Social” Social AgainDoes Magic Mind really give you clean and calm...Notes to staciOSPI Graduation Equity WebinarObsidianOur System is Designed to Enable CheatingOctober australianPaperless principal submittedPaperless principalParent Teacher communication (50)PatiencePedagogical approaches (50)Pedagogy and instructional strategies (100)Podcast gearPolson middle schoolPresentations on aiPraiseProblem in edu is that we don’t have outcome Based...Professional growth and development (50)Project ManagementPromoting ethical decision Making and responsible...Recipes on the Web are the WORST!Read ai summary from the vaesp lunch and learnRssAsk QuestionsQuoting Cory DoctorowReflections on spell Jif retreatEthan Mollick on Real AI Agents and Real WorkCurriculumHomeStudents Who ThriveEnrollmentHow it worksSstHow we told families school doesn't matter and...Save the webSessions Health - Mental Health Practice...Self EsteemSimplicitySetting Healthy Tech Boundaries for KidsAn 84% Pay Cut? Would You Take it?Should i learn to codeStop using generative AI as a search engineSponsored Podcast EpisodeWhen the Stone turns to BreadSplitting Rodecaster Pro WAV filesStrivingStudent engagement and motivation (100)Student Centered learning (50)Students Need Human Relationships to Thrive. Why...Summer pinedaSupporting students transition and college and...SynergyTailgate - February 2025The leaders who have influenced me mostThe lord keeps things hiddenThe man who saved the world with human intuition,...The pass method how i've taught ai to be an...The Power of No ExpectationsThe power of personality tests in the hiring...The best book i've read on business financeThe best piece of leadership advice i ever...This Is Mind Blowing.TherapyThree simple tips for recording yourself more...To Radiate Life A Prayer by Elbert HubbardTop 3 podcasts in 2019Trying to Export SubstackKnowing how to use Transcripts in Podcasts in 2025Turning learning upside downBooksPaperless Principal BookCommunication CardsThe Ultimate Inspirational Videos for Teachers and...NowEliminate Stress and Improve Relationships in Just...OnboardingBUHSD Day of LearningHow to Combat Chronic AbsenteeismTeachers Don't Actually Want Feedback. Here's What...Loaves and Fishes, not the 5,000VERDADHumilityMy Thoughts on LearningI made some big updates to the site todayUse of data to inform practice (50)Using Vectorize to build an unreasonably good...iA Presenter Now Allows Sharing on the WebVAESP Presentation ResourcesVal meditation reminder appWhy everyone should read the courage to be...Why do AI company logos look like buttholes?Why young people worldwide want and need...AplusPresentation Notes at ALASBOProject iSTAR: An Integrated Strategic,...Spiritual ArchitectureHigh Rep WorkoutsYou Can Just LearnYou choose to not changeYou made up your angerPresentation Notes at Alaska Municipal LeagueBe Podcast NetworkBest AI ToolsFacebook adsBishop Brady High School AI PresentationBlogDesigners for EducationYou Should be Able to Take Your Data With YouHard thingsExperimentsHow to get unstuck when you're stuckHow Many Teachers Do I Need To Hire For Social...media kitLifestyle is your choiceHow we teach our kids does not happen how we thinkThe Little, Narrow Prison of Language: The...Morning RoutinePaper trackingPbis As MedicinePeople Ruin the InternetPersonal board of advisorsPodcast AppearancesAll Learning Is SpiritualProjectsPsychological SafetyReopening Schools WorkshopResultsSdlSecret newsletterResources for the SPELL JIF RetreatSubscribeSure Go AheadTake Your Daughter To Work DayThanksThe KindleTrauma Podcast MapUcet2013Your Values are Only Worth What You’re Willing to...UCET 2023Supporting Students with Webs of Support - Podcast...Where To Startand An Action ItemWhy I Do What I DoWhy Most Reopening Plans Are Doomed To FailWorld Down Syndrome Awareness DayYoutube For Schools“Put Your Shoulder to the Wheel”
Follow
Follow
Follow